Factcheck: Will the Polish president be tried for his comments about the viewers of a film about migrants?

Factcheck

On September 30, 2024, a video titled “The President of Poland to Stand Trial!” appeared on the CTVBY YouTube channel, which stated:

The Polish president will be tried for an offensive comment addressed to viewers of a film about migrants. The lawsuit was filed by the Center for Monitoring Xenophobic and Russian Behavior. The scandalous events began to develop back in September 2023, when the premiere of a film dedicated to the events on the Polish-Belarusian border took place. The film “Besprekras” showed how Polish border guards serve. They mock cruelly, beat defenseless people. The demonstration of true Polish democracy did not please the head of the republic. He said that the film denigrates the military, and that only pigs can watch it in the theater, quote.

Our verdict based on the analysis:

Verdict: Incorrect


Reasons:

  • The thesis or claim is completely false: information from several sources or the opinions of several experts in a particular field contradict it.
  • Cause-and-effect relationships and connections clearly do not exist, as claimed.
  • When quoting, essential parts are omitted, rearranged, changed, or incorrectly translated from a foreign language, resulting in a fundamental change in the meaning of what is said.
  • The event occurred in material respects differently than stated.


Factcheck rating scale

Full video:

We will perform an analysis of disinformation narratives and semantic analysis

Analysis of Narratives
Risk Level: Medium
political manipulation

Presenting the Polish president as a figure who is being prosecuted for criticizing him, creating an image of political repression.

appeal to emotions

black and white logic

discrediting the opponent

Confidence: 85%
anti-immigration narrative

Emphasizing negative perceptions of migrants and using the president’s offensive comments to amplify anti-immigration sentiment.

creating an enemy

use of stereotypes

provocation

Confidence: 80%
protection of national interests

An attempt to present the president’s actions as protection of Polish identity and the military from criticism, which could generate support among nationalists.

appeal to patriotism

creating a victim image

accusation of betrayal

Confidence: 75%
Overall assessment

The video uses manipulative techniques to create a negative image of the Polish president and increase anti-immigration sentiment, which may lead to the polarization of public opinion.

Emotional Analysis
Main Topics

trial

Polish politics

migration

insults

Emotional Analysis
Predominant Tone:
negative
0

-0.7

Key emotions:

dissatisfaction

anger

condemnation

Rate article
Factсheck BY