Debunking the disinformation: Is it true that Ukrainians shot civilians?

Factcheck

On August 28, 2024, the SB TV YouTube channel posted a material with a very dangerous manipulative title “Called the Armed Forces of Ukraine fascists. The girl was shot in front of her five-year-old sister in Sudzha!” and the following content:

Two people, they were definitely Ukrainians. There was one, he spoke a language other than Russian. Probably, I don’t know. He took people out into the street. He went into the yard. My neighbor got it really bad, a young girl, 25 years old. She was shot in front of my eyes because she said that they have fascists and that’s it. And was it a mercenary who shot? No, a Ukrainian. A Ukrainian, right? The main thing is that I saw covid several times. I also have a little sister, she was 5 years old. And where she is, I don’t know. Did your sister see it too? Yes, she did. But she ran away to the neighbor, and that’s it.

Our verdict based on the analysis:

Verdict: Incorrect


Reasons:

  • The thesis or assertion is completely false: information from several sources or the opinions of several experts in a particular field contradict it.
  • Cause-and-effect relationships and connections clearly do not exist, as claimed.
  • The event occurred in material respects differently than stated.


Fact Check Rating Scale

The full video, which has collected 2.6 million views:

We will perform an analysis of disinformation narratives and semantic analysis

Analysis of Narratives
Risk Level: High
discrediting the enemy

A narrative that attempts to portray Ukrainians as fascists and aggressors, which creates a negative image of the enemy.

generalization

appeal to emotion

use of personal tragedy

Confidence: 85%
victim and trauma

A narrative that highlights the suffering and trauma experienced by bystanders to a conflict in order to evoke empathy and support.

evoking empathy

using children’s imagery

sharing personal experience

Confidence: 75%
Overall assessment

The video contains strong manipulative elements aimed at creating a negative image of Ukrainians and focusing on personal tragediesyah, which can contribute to the spread of misinformation and the strengthening of conflict sentiments.

Emotional Analysis
Main Topics

the impact of war on children

violence and trauma

conflict in Ukraine

Emotional analysis
Predominant tone:
negative
0

-0.8

Key emotions:

fear

anger

grief

Rate article
Factсheck BY